murray's ice cream

menu

Frozen Desserts

At Murray's, we have over 30 flavors of Hard Ice Cream by the scoop, Soft Serve Ice Cream, Italian Ice, and Frozen Yogurt. 

Our ice cream is locally sourced from multiple local farms in New York for the freshest ice cream you can buy. Using the finest ingredients and freshest milk, Murray's Ice Cream is simple, wholesome and most importantly, delicious. 

Our current flavors are on our new menu boards to the left. We have dairy free & sugar free Italian Ice options as well as gluten free options for Ice Cream, Italian Ice & Yogurt. 

If you have any allergies to gluten, dairy, or nuts, please let us know when you come in and we will be happy to let you know your options. We use special scoopers for nut products, that are only used to scoop our nut ice creams, so you can rest assured that our non-nut options are nut free!

Specialty Items

At Murray's, we have many custom specialty items that we promise you won't want to miss. 

Classic items include Sundaes and Banana Splits, but we also offer some more custom items like our "Cup of Dirt", "Manhattan Special" and the  "Mixer".

We also have smoothies in Mango and Strawberry Banana. We recommend adding in some soft serve ice cream for extra deliciousness! 

Ice Cream Cakes
& Custom Novelties

At Murray's, we custom make our ice cream cakes to order. We have various size options from 6 inches all the way up to a 1/4 sheet cake that can serve 20-25 people! All of our cakes are made with a layer of chocolate ice cream, vanilla ice cream, and extra chocolate crunchies. If you call ahead, you can also customize your flavors to any of our ice cream flavors!

We also have special Oreo cakes, which are made with vanilla ice cream with tons of Oreos mixed right into the cake. And if that weren't enough, the cake is topped with even more Oreos, drizzled with chocolate syrup. 

All cakes are made on the premises daily, 100% fresh! We even can make the cakes with gluten free ice cream flavors and gluten free crunchies.

In addition, we have pre-packaged items ready to go, though we can customize these with ANY flavor you'd like with 2 hours notice!

Murray Saucers: 6-pack of ice cream sandwiches on chocolate wafers

Cookie Sandwiches: 6-pack of ice cream sandwiches on chocolate chip cookies

Oreo Sandwiches: 6-pack of ice cream sandwiches on large Oreo cookies

 

Ice Cream Cupcakes: 6-pack; chocolate cup with an edible shell, with a scoop of ice cream (instead of cake!), frosting and sprinkles (or other toppings)

Milkshakes & 
Specialty Drinks

At Murray's, we have an endless supply of milkshake options. From your classic milkshake topped with whipped cream, we also have malted milkshakes and hot fudge milkshakes.

Our newest creation are our Emoji and Poop Emoji shakes. The Emoji shake is a spin on the classic milkshake, with the addition of rainbow sprinkles and an emoji lollipop. Our most popular milkshake is the Poop Emoji Shake, which is a chocolate overload with chocolate ice cream, chocolate crunchies, chocolate sprinkles, chocolate chips, and chocolate syrup topped with whipped cream. 

Our custom drinks (some of which were named by customers, like "The Sydney") are the perfect refreshing treat on a hot summer day. We have classic options like Coke and Root Beer Floats, but also some special items like the "Summer Sizzler" and "Blue Sweet Tart"